Tuesday, January 16, 2018
Review: Well, first off, its an inoffensive episode, so that's a plus. Like the previous episode, it tries to ride on the success of a classic episode, in this case Team Homer. Unlike the previous episode, it doesn't make every attempt to ruin or otherwise dismantle Team Homer's supposed legacy, using the Pin Pals only to set up a bowling storyline.
The episode is paced oddly. As Team Homer already did a "they play against teams comprised of Springfield citizens", this episode felt the need to do it again to progress the plot but rushed through it so that it wasn't just a complete retread. The main storyline focuses on their new opponent, the hedge fund team who hustle Moe, befriend Bart and irk Lisa just enough to make her a subtle hero yet again. The episode doesn't really do a good job at setting these plotlines up; Bart and Lisa's plotlines feel rushed and the plot with Moe attempts to take a sideturn at the end which just falls flat.
Oh, and the jokes were half okay and half not that great. Most of the misses involve the hedge fund team, they just weren't that funny. The episode ends up okay, but it definitely could've been better with what it tried to do.
Final Score: 6.8
Wednesday, January 10, 2018
Recap: Marge runs for and is elected Mayor of Springfield, but as she's unable to fulfill her promises, Homer's oafish demeanor allows her to retain decent approval ratings.
Review: The first half of the episode was irredeemable garbage, with the blatant, practically shameless referencing and disregard of Marge vs. the Monorail, so poorly done it was even worse than the heavy-handed political references that littered the episode.
The episode is barely salvaged by a stronger second-half, after Homer's bumbling helps Marge out. The jokes were stronger overall in the second half, which keeps the episode from tanking completely. Better than what I was expecting, but that's not saying much.
Final Score: 5.0
Tuesday, November 7, 2017
Review: The Grampa sidestory, and it was a side story despite it claiming the episode's title, starts off decently enough but after Grampa learns people mock him often the story takes a back seat and then ends on a dull, pointless note with little payoff.
The Skinner story, which I believe is the first case of the show actively ignoring The Principal and the Pauper, was better overall. It had funnier gags, the stuff with Ohio State was decent albeit with a few misses, and it had better plot development overall although it, too, had a rather tame end.
Its kind of odd, the episode really didn't know how to end itself. Its not like the ending needed to be rushed; the episode had the full, entire open, an extended couch gag, and a lengthening unrelated bit at the end because the episode itself was so short; that time could've been used to create a much more satisfying conclusion to both plot lines. Sad, really.
Final Score: 6.7
Tuesday, October 31, 2017
The Exor-Sis - Maggie gets possessed by a lesser demon in an obvious Exorcist spoof. (+0.6)
Coralisa - Lisa finds a stitched-up CGI version of her world through her room, where life is great except everyone has their eyes or mouths stitched up with buttons. (+0.7)
Mmm... Homer - Homer realizes he tastes delicious, and eventually becomes the world's tastiest ingredient. (+0.9)
Review: I enjoyed the episode overall. Each segment was better than the last. Exor-Sis was kinda dull and ended on a whimper. Coralisa, an apparent Coraline reference, was relatively faithful to the setup of that movie even if, once again, it had no idea how to end itself. The last segment had some good moments though the 'Hallelujah' bits dragged it down somewhat. This Treehouse of Horror ends up better than last years' if only because none of the segments were downright bad, and overall this one is the best scoring one in five years, but these anthologies are still a far cry from what they were even just ten years ago.
Final Score: 7.2
Monday, October 23, 2017
Review: Overall, its a dull episode. A few jokes worked, a few jokes didn't. Maggie's plotline was borderline ridiculous which didn't help matters. Episode could've fared better with more mafia gags as they were the best part of the episode. Better than the other two episodes of this season, of course that's not saying much.
Final Score: 6.2
Tuesday, October 10, 2017
Review: There's two things I liked about the episode: the scenes at the community college and most of the side banter with Homer and Bart. Those two things saved the episode from a much worse fate. The whole latter third of the episode with the off-the-wall play was terrible, and the scene at the comicon panel with the "guest stars" was high-level cringe-core which was even worse. Those two things, which were basically half of the episode, spiraled it downward from 'decent' territory to 'only watch for the artwork, maybe' tier.
Final Score: 5.6
Thursday, October 5, 2017
Review: When the opening began, I figured this would be a straight-up Game of Thrones reference of an episode. It ended up as more of a basic medieval-themed episode albeit with references to GoT and other similar worlds. A lot of it was terrible, though. The main plot focused primarily on Marge, Lisa, and Jacqueline whatever-her-last-name-in-this-world-is, and it is a terribly dry plot at that, medieval themed or not. Most of the jokes either fell flat or were just embarrassing (one "Krusty has genital Smurfs" was stupid enough, I didn't need several more of it). You can categorize this under the already-stuffed "episode about thing writers like but have no idea how to properly parody".
Final Score: 3.5